Question 1

What is the asking price for 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City?

Accepted Answer

458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City is listed at $1,049,900 ($328/sqft).  This listing is currently active and available for showings.

Question 2

How many bedrooms and bathrooms does 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City have?

Accepted Answer

This Residential features 5 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms, 3,203 square feet of living space. It is a 3-story home. The lot is 0.52 acres.

Question 3

When was 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City built?

Accepted Answer

This property was built in 2001, making it 25 years old. Built in the early 2000s, the home benefits from modern construction standards and may have updated systems.

Question 4

What type of property is 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City?

Accepted Answer

458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City is a Residential (Single Family Residence). The architectural style is Tudor. It is located in the BUTTERCUP EST #46 subdivision. Zoning: Single-Family.

Question 5

Does 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City have a garage or parking?

Accepted Answer

Yes, this property includes a 2-car garage. Total parking capacity: 2 vehicles.

Question 6

Is there an HOA for 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City?

Accepted Answer

Yes, this property is part of a homeowners association. HOA fees are $3,000 annually. HOA fees typically cover shared amenities, landscaping, and community maintenance.

Question 7

What are the property taxes for 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City?

Accepted Answer

Annual property taxes for this property are approximately $3,137 (about $261/month). This represents an effective tax rate of approximately 0.30% of the list price. Property taxes in Utah vary by county and are subject to change.

Question 8

What are the key features of 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City?

Accepted Answer

Interior features include: Bath: Primary, Bath: Sep. Tub/Shower, Disposal, Range/Oven: Free Stdng., Vaulted Ceilings. Exterior features include: Balcony, Patio: Covered, Sliding Glass Doors, Walkout. The home has 2 fireplaces.   View: Lake,Mountain(s).

Question 9

Is 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City a good deal?

Accepted Answer

Propaired's AI deal analysis classifies this property as a "Standard" with a deal score of 45/100. Key deal signals: 4.5% year-over-year market appreciation. The price is 9% above similar homes in the area. This analysis considers price relative to comparables, days on market, price reductions, and market conditions.

Question 10

How does this price compare to similar homes in Garden City?

Accepted Answer

The median price for similar properties in the area is $962,500 (based on 10 homes). At $1,049,900, this listing is 9% above the median for comparable homes. It ranks #Above Similar among similar listings by value.

Question 11

What would the monthly mortgage payment be for 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City?

Accepted Answer

At the current 30-year mortgage rate of 6.36% with 20% down, the estimated monthly principal and interest payment is $5,232. Including estimated taxes and HOA fees, the total monthly cost is approximately $8,493. A 15-year mortgage at 5.71% would be $6,957/month but saves significantly on interest. These are estimates — contact a lender for a personalized quote.

Question 12

How long has 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City been on the market?

Accepted Answer

This property has been listed for 44 days. The average days on market in Garden City is 150 days, meaning this listing is moving faster than the local average.

Question 13

What lifestyle features does 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City offer?

Accepted Answer

Propaired's AI has identified 2 lifestyle features for this property: Pool, Scenic Views. The primary lifestyle niche is "scenic_views." These tags are derived from MLS data, property features, and location analysis.

Question 14

Is 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City near skiing?

Accepted Answer

This property is within reach of skiing. Beaver Mountain Resort is 8.0 miles away. Utah's world-class resorts offer 500+ inches of annual snowfall and "The Greatest Snow on Earth."

Question 15

Does 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City have a pool?

Accepted Answer

Yes, this property includes a private pool.  Utah summers can reach 100°F+, making a pool a valuable amenity. Consider seasonal maintenance costs of approximately $2,000-$4,000/year for a Utah pool.

Question 16

What recreation is near 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City?

Accepted Answer

This property has a recreation score of 83/100. Nearby recreation includes: Limber Pine Nature trailhead (3.6 mi); Heritage Park park (0.3 mi); Bear Lake Golf Course (2.4 mi); Bear Lake State Park (2.1 mi). Skiing: Beaver Mountain Resort (8.0 mi). Utah offers world-class outdoor recreation year-round, from skiing to hiking to national parks.

Question 17

Are there hiking trails near 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City?

Accepted Answer

Yes, the nearest trailhead is Limber Pine Nature, just 3.6 miles from the property. Bear Lake State Park is 2.1 miles away. Utah has over 10,000 miles of hiking trails across its diverse terrain, from desert canyons to alpine meadows.

Question 18

What amenities and services are near 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City?

Accepted Answer

This property has an amenity proximity score of 94/100. Nearby services include: Grocery: Bear Lake Market (1.1 mi); Hospital: Keith W. Kent, NP (23.9 mi); Pharmacy: Bear Lake Drug Garden City (0.6 mi); Dining: Bear Lake Pizza Co (0.8 mi). Gas station: 0.9 miles. Gym: The Shed Fit 365 (1.3 mi).

Question 19

How far is the nearest hospital from 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City?

Accepted Answer

The nearest hospital is Keith W. Kent, NP, approximately 23.9 miles from the property. The nearest fire station is 1.0 miles away. Proximity to emergency services is an important safety factor for homebuyers.

Question 20

What schools serve 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City?

Accepted Answer

Assigned schools: Elementary: North Rich; Middle: Rich; High: Rich.   School district: Rich.

Question 21

What high school is near 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City?

Accepted Answer

The nearest high school is Rich. View the full school profile on Propaired for test scores, enrollment, and student-to-teacher ratios.

Question 22

What elementary school is near 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City?

Accepted Answer

The nearest elementary school is North Rich. Propaired provides full school ratings and comparison data for all schools in this area.

Question 23

What middle school is near 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City?

Accepted Answer

The nearest middle school is Rich.

Question 24

What is the internet speed at 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City?

Accepted Answer

This property has a broadband score of 85/100 (Excellent). Best available speed: 500 Mbps download / 100 Mbps upload. Fiber is not currently available at this address. Available providers: CentraCom (500 Mbps, Fixed Wireless); CentraCom (10 Mbps, DSL); HughesNet (100 Mbps, Satellite). Total providers: 5.

Question 25

Is 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City in a flood zone?

Accepted Answer

This property is classified as low.  Flood insurance is not typically required but may be recommended.  Always verify current FEMA maps as they are periodically updated.

Question 26

How does this listing compare to the Garden City market?

Accepted Answer

458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City is listed at $1,049,900, which is above the Garden City median of $670,000 by $379,900. There are currently 168 active listings in Garden City. Homes in Garden City sell in an average of 150 days. The average sale-to-list ratio is 97.1%.

Question 27

What is the Garden City real estate market like in 2026?

Accepted Answer

In 2026, the median home price in Garden City is $670,000. There are currently 168 active listings. Homes sell in an average of 150 days. The average sale-to-list ratio is 97.1%. This listing at $1,049,900 is above the Garden City 2026 median.

Question 28

Are there other homes for sale in Garden City?

Accepted Answer

Yes — there are currently 168 active listings in Garden City. Browse all Garden City homes for sale at propaired.ai/listings/ut/garden-city. Prices range around a median of $670,000. Homes in Garden City are selling in about 150 days on average.

Question 29

How does this price compare to the Utah state average?

Accepted Answer

At $1,049,900, this property is above the Utah state median of $517,990 by $531,910. Garden City prices are 29% above the state average. Utah's housing market varies significantly by region — front-range cities near SLC are typically more expensive than rural areas.

Question 30

What is the Propaired intelligence score for 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City?

Accepted Answer

This property has a Propaired intelligence score of 62/100, combining deal value (45), recreation access (83), amenity proximity (94), broadband quality (85), and lifestyle features (2 tags). This composite score helps buyers quickly identify properties that match their priorities.

Question 31

What heating and cooling systems does 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City have?

Accepted Answer

Heating: Gas: Radiant,Propane,Wood. Cooling: Central Air. Modern HVAC systems typically last 15-20 years with proper maintenance. Utah's climate ranges from sub-zero winters to 100°F+ summers, making reliable heating and cooling essential.

Question 32

What type of roof does 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City have?

Accepted Answer

The roof material is Asphalt. Asphalt shingles typically last 20-30 years in Utah's climate. With a 25-year-old home, reviewing recent roof inspections is recommended.

Question 33

Does 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City have a basement?

Accepted Answer

Yes, the basement is described as: Daylight,Entrance,Full,Walk-Out Access. A daylight basement features windows for natural light, making the space more livable. Check for any signs of moisture or foundation issues during the home inspection.

Question 34

What is 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City constructed from?

Accepted Answer

Construction materials include: Cinder Block,Stone,Cement Siding. Stone construction provides exceptional durability and a premium aesthetic.

Question 35

What type of flooring does 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City have?

Accepted Answer

Flooring types include: Carpet,Laminate,Tile.  Tile flooring is durable and ideal for high-traffic areas and bathrooms. Carpeted areas provide warmth and comfort, especially in bedrooms.

Question 36

What are the water and sewer connections for 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City?

Accepted Answer

Water source: Culinary. Sewer: Sewer: Connected,Sewer: Public.  Municipal sewer service means no septic maintenance costs. Water is a critical consideration in Utah's arid climate.

Question 37

What shopping and dining is near 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City?

Accepted Answer

The nearest restaurant is Bear Lake Pizza Co (0.8 miles away) and the nearest grocery store is Bear Lake Market (1.1 miles). Coffee: Moose Buns (0.9 mi). Banking: Zions Bank (1.6 mi). Overall amenity proximity score: 94/100.

Question 38

What would homeowner's insurance cost for 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City?

Accepted Answer

Homeowner's insurance in Utah typically ranges from 0.3% to 0.5% of the home's value annually. For a home listed at $1,049,900, expect approximately $3,150-$5,250/year ($263-$438/month).   Get multiple quotes — rates vary significantly by insurer.

Question 39

What are the estimated closing costs for 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City?

Accepted Answer

Closing costs in Utah typically range from 2-5% of the purchase price. For a home at $1,049,900, expect approximately $20,998-$52,495 in closing costs. This includes title insurance, escrow fees, lender fees, recording fees, and prepaid items (insurance, taxes). Buyers should also budget for a home inspection ($300-$500), appraisal ($400-$600), and any lender-required reserves.

Question 40

How does the property tax compare to the list price at 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City?

Accepted Answer

The annual property tax of $3,137 represents an effective rate of 0.30% relative to the list price of $1,049,900. This is below the Utah average effective rate of approximately 0.58%, which is favorable for the buyer. Property taxes in Utah are assessed by the county and can change when the property is sold.

Question 41

What are the total estimated monthly costs for 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City?

Accepted Answer

Estimated total monthly housing cost: $8,843. This includes principal & interest ($5,232 at 6.36% with 20% down), property tax ($261/mo), HOA ($3,000/mo), and estimated insurance (~$350/mo). Actual costs will vary based on your down payment, credit score, and insurance quotes.

Question 42

Is 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City eligible for FHA or VA financing?

Accepted Answer

At $1,049,900, this property may exceed standard FHA loan limits and could require a conventional or jumbo loan. VA loans have no price cap but require VA eligibility.    Consult a mortgage lender for personalized eligibility.

Question 43

Could 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City be a 1031 exchange property?

Accepted Answer

Yes, 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City could potentially qualify for a 1031 like-kind exchange if used as an investment or business property. A 1031 exchange allows deferral of capital gains taxes by reinvesting proceeds from one investment property into another. Key requirements include identifying a replacement property within 45 days and closing within 180 days. The property must be held for investment purposes — personal residences do not qualify. Consult a qualified intermediary and tax advisor for specific guidance.

Question 44

How does 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City compare to recently sold homes nearby?

Accepted Answer

Based on 10 comparable properties, the median sold price in this area is $962,500. This listing is 9% above the comparable median. It ranks Above Similar among similar listings by value. The median for this property type specifically is $779,900. Comparable analysis is based on similar size, age, and location.

Question 45

Is the Garden City neighborhood appreciating in value?

Accepted Answer

Based on Zillow Home Value Index data, property values in this area have appreciated 4.5% over the past year. The current Zillow Home Value Index for this area is $419,147. This listing is priced at 251% of the ZHVI estimate. Past appreciation is not a guarantee of future performance.

Question 46

What is the price trend in Garden City?

Accepted Answer

Garden City's median price has decreased 4.2% month-over-month. Current median: $670,000. Days on market have increased by 50.4% month-over-month. Homes are selling at 97.1% of list price on average. Monitor these trends to time your offer strategically.

Question 47

Is 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City overpriced or underpriced?

Accepted Answer

Propaired's AI classifies this property as "Standard." At 9% above comparable homes, the asking price is above the local median. Verify that premium features justify the price difference. Deal score: 45/100. Always confirm with a local real estate professional who can provide a comparative market analysis.

Question 48

What school district is 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City in?

Accepted Answer

This property is in the Rich school district. Assigned elementary: North Rich. Assigned middle: Rich. Assigned high: Rich. School district boundaries can affect property values by 5-15%. Contact the district directly to confirm current enrollment boundaries, as they may change.

Question 49

What parks are near 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City?

Accepted Answer

The nearest local park is Heritage Park (0.3 miles away). The nearest state park is Bear Lake State Park (2.1 miles).  Parks and green spaces contribute to quality of life and are a positive factor for property values.

Question 50

Is there a golf course near 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City?

Accepted Answer

The nearest golf course is Bear Lake Golf Course, 2.4 miles from the property. Utah has over 80 golf courses statewide with a season running from March through November in most areas. Close proximity to a golf course is a desirable feature that can enhance property value.

Question 51

What water activities are near 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City?

Accepted Answer

Water recreation near this property includes: Bear Lake (4.6 mi); boat ramp at Bear Lake State Park (2.2 mi).  Utah offers diverse water recreation from mountain reservoirs to desert lakes. Popular activities include boating, kayaking, paddle boarding, and fishing — a Utah fishing license is required for anglers.

Question 52

Is 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City move-in ready?

Accepted Answer

Property condition is listed as: Blt./Standing.

Question 53

What updates might 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City need?

Accepted Answer

At 25 years old, common updates to consider include: HVAC system update. Current roof: Asphalt. Current heating: Gas: Radiant,Propane,Wood. These are general guidelines based on typical component lifespans — the actual condition depends on maintenance history. Always get a professional inspection and ask the seller for maintenance records and any recent upgrades.

Question 54

Does 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City come with a home warranty?

Accepted Answer

No home warranty is currently included with this property. Buyers can request a home warranty as part of the purchase negotiation — they typically cost $400-$700/year and cover major systems and appliances. This is especially valuable for older homes.

Question 55

What is the lot like at 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City?

Accepted Answer

The lot is 0.52 acres. Lot features: Road: Paved,Terrain: Grad Slope,View: Lake,View: Mountain. Terrain: Road: Paved, Terrain: Grad Slope, View: Lake, View: Mountain. Views: Lake,Mountain(s).  Lot characteristics affect usability, privacy, and future improvement potential.

Question 56

What utilities are available at 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City?

Accepted Answer

Available utilities include: Natural Gas Not Available,Electricity Connected,Sewer Connected,Sewer: Public. Water source: Culinary. Sewer: Sewer: Connected,Sewer: Public. Utility costs in Utah vary by season — expect higher heating bills in winter and cooling costs in summer. Contact local utility providers for average monthly cost estimates for this address.

Question 57

Does 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City have natural gas?

Accepted Answer

Yes, this property has natural gas service — the heating system is listed as: Gas: Radiant,Propane,Wood. Natural gas is the most common and cost-effective heating fuel in Utah, typically 30-50% less expensive than electric heating. The cooling system (Central Air) operates separately. Natural gas availability also supports gas ranges, water heaters, and fireplaces.

Question 58

Is there EV charging near 458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City?

Accepted Answer

The nearest EV charging station is ChargePoint Charging Station, approximately 1.0 miles from the property. With a 2-car garage, installing a home Level 2 EV charger is straightforward — most installations cost $500-$2,000 including the charger. Utah offers a growing EV charging network along major corridors and in urban centers. Convenient public charging is available nearby for supplemental needs.

458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City, UT 84028

458 W BUTTERCUP LN, Garden City, UT 84028

About This Property

Features & Amenities

Property Info

Financial

Structure & Systems

Parking

Property Intelligence

Lifestyle

Flood Zone

Deal Analysis

Investment Potential

Short-Term Rental

Recreation & Amenities

Recreation Nearby
Score: 83/100

Amenities Nearby
Score: 94/100

Internet & Connectivity

All Property Details

Property Info

Bedrooms & Baths

Financial

Structure

Lot & Land

Parking

Amenities

Utilities

Schools

Timeline

Garden City Market Context

Connect with a Buyer’s Agent

Similar Homes

$175,000

$699,000

$825,000

$1,100,000

$540,000

Find Your Dream Home

Frequently Asked Questions

Discover

458 BUTTERCUP, Garden City, UT 84028

458 W BUTTERCUP LN, Garden City, UT 84028

About This Property

Features & Amenities

Property Info

Financial

Structure & Systems

Parking

Property Intelligence

Lifestyle

Flood Zone

Deal Analysis

Investment Potential

Short-Term Rental

Recreation & Amenities

Recreation NearbyScore: 83/100

Amenities NearbyScore: 94/100

Internet & Connectivity

All Property Details

Property Info

Bedrooms & Baths

Financial

Structure

Lot & Land

Parking

Amenities

Utilities

Schools

Timeline

Garden City Market Context

Connect with a Buyer’s Agent

Similar Homes

$175,000

$699,000

$825,000

$1,100,000

$540,000

Find Your Dream Home

Frequently Asked Questions

Discover

Recreation Nearby
Score: 83/100

Amenities Nearby
Score: 94/100