1035 MONTEZUMA, Monticello, UT 84535
4BD/—BA Residential in Monticello, UT 84535. 3,700 sqft. Built 1996. Listed at $2,500,000. MLS #2174300.
4BD/—BA Residential in Monticello, UT 84535. 3,700 sqft. Built 1996. Listed at $2,500,000. MLS #2174300.
A rare opportunity to own one of the American Southwest's most extraordinary private estates. Encompassing more than 103 acres in spectacular Montezuma Canyon, this remarkable property is framed by soaring sandstone cliffs, towering cottonwoods, seasonal creek frontage, productive vineyards, mature orchards, and centuries of cultural history. Designed for both luxury living and self-sufficiency, the estate includes a beautifully crafted 3,700-square-foot Santa Fe-inspired main residence, a charming guest cabin, bunkhouse, historic sheepherder wagon, barns, workshops, and extensive agricultural improvements. Three solar systems, two wells, four septic systems, and significant water resources create an exceptional level of independence rarely found in today's luxury market. The estate's vineyard offers the best of both worlds-producing premium Merlot, Chardonnay, Riesling, and Chenin Blanc grapes while being professionally maintained through an established partnership with a respected Palisade, Colorado winery. The grapes are cultivated, harvested, and crafted into finished wines by the winery, allowing owners to enjoy the prestige of vineyard ownership with minimal ongoing maintenance. Combined with a mature fruit orchard, productive gardens, and irrigated pastures, the property offers an exceptional agricultural lifestyle that is both beautiful and remarkably manageable. Ancient Puebloan cultural sites, two developed sandstone caves, breathtaking red rock landscapes, and exceptional privacy combine to create an ownership experience that is as inspiring as it is rare. Whether envisioned as a private family legacy estate, luxury retreat, boutique hospitality destination, vineyard, or conservation property, the possibilities are extraordinary. Located within easy reach of Bears Ears National Monument, Mesa Verde National Park, Monument Valley, Moab, and the Four Corners region, this is more than a luxury property, it is a once-in-a-generation opportunity to steward one of the Southwest's most remarkable private landscapes. Qualified buyers only. Showings by appointment with advance notice and proof of funds. Seller may consider owner financing with a substantial down payment.
Property Type
Residential
Property Style
Single Family Residence
Architectural Style
Southwest
Stories
1
County
San Juan
Zoning
Agricultural
Construction
Cedar,Frame,Log,Stucco
Lot Size
103.6 sq ft
Above Grade Area
3,700 sq ft
Condition
Blt./Standing
MLS #
2174300
Property Type
Residential
Property Style
Single Family Residence
Architectural Style
Southwest
Stories
1
County
San Juan
Zoning
Agricultural
Construction
Cedar,Frame,Log,Stucco
Lot Size
103.6 sq ft
Above Grade Area
3,700 sq ft
Condition
Blt./Standing
MLS #
2174300
List Price
$2,500,000
Annual Taxes
$2,472
Home Warranty
No
List Price
$2,500,000
Annual Taxes
$2,472
Home Warranty
No
Heating
Active Solar,Wall Furnace,Wood
Cooling
Active Solar
Roof
Composition,Flat,Metal,Pitched
Flooring
Hardwood,Laminate,Tile
Basement
Slab
Materials
Cedar,Frame,Log,Stucco
Patio & Porch
Covered,Porch: Open
Water Source
Culinary,Irrigation,Irrigation: Pressure,Rights: Owned,Rights: Rented,Shares,Well
Sewer
Septic Tank
View
Mountain(s),Valley,View: Red Rock
Heating
Active Solar,Wall Furnace,Wood
Cooling
Active Solar
Roof
Composition,Flat,Metal,Pitched
Flooring
Hardwood,Laminate,Tile
Basement
Slab
Materials
Cedar,Frame,Log,Stucco
Patio & Porch
Covered,Porch: Open
Water Source
Culinary,Irrigation,Irrigation: Pressure,Rights: Owned,Rights: Rented,Shares,Well
Sewer
Septic Tank
View
Mountain(s),Valley,View: Red Rock
Garage Spaces
3
Covered Spaces
3
Total Parking
3
Garage Spaces
3
Covered Spaces
3
Total Parking
3
Classification
Standard
Deal Score
10/100
vs Market Median
19% above
Area Growth (YoY)
-1.7%
Deal Score Breakdown
10/100
Priced 19% above the per-subtype city median
-1.7% year-over-year ZHVI growth in this area
STR net cashflow -$14,058/mo (-86.3% return). Uses the better of LT or STR against total monthly ownership cost (P&I, tax, insurance, HOA, maintenance).
No price reduction from original list
Not enough comparable listings
Ensemble scoring: the best single signal sets the floor, secondary qualifying signals (≥60) each add 5 points up to +20. A home that strongly wins on one dimension is already a great deal — it doesn't need to tick every box.
Est. Annual Revenue
$38,188/yr
$252/night · 44% occupancy · $103/bedroom · $0.18/sqft
Net Monthly Cash Flow
−$14,060 /mo (−$168,717/yr)
Monthly STR income
Monthly ownership cost
Coverage
20%
Net /mo
−$14,058
DSCR
0.17
$286,250
+773% vs median
186 days
16
$264,900 – $1,895,000
$2,472
Select agents you’d like to hear from. They’ll be notified of your interest — your contact details stay private until you choose to respond.
Your inquiry goes to the listing agent.
Fast Response
Typically within 2 hours during business hours
Built with AI to help you find your perfect home
Powered by AI • Secured by Supabase • Trusted by Agents