3823 OLD HIGHWAY 91, New Harmony, UT 84757
4BD/—BA Residential in New Harmony, UT 84757. 3,725 sqft. Built 2018. Listed at $1,190,000. MLS #2155476.
4BD/—BA Residential in New Harmony, UT 84757. 3,725 sqft. Built 2018. Listed at $1,190,000. MLS #2155476.
Escape to your own private retreat in New Harmony, Utah. Situated on 5 secluded acres with stunning mountain views, this one- of-a-kind property offers the perfect blend of privacy, comfort, and functionality. Natural light fills the home, centered around a unique enclosed courtyard that creates warmth and character throughout. Thoughtful craftsmanship shines with granite countertops, knotty alder doors, reclaimed elm wood accents, and durable polished concrete flooring. Designed for flexibility and lifestyle, the property features a dedicated pottery room/hobby space/man cave, plus a separate casita/mother-in-law quarters-- ideal for guests or multigenerational living. Several custom-built furniture pieces are seamlessly integrated, adding both charm and function. Built with efficiency in mind, the home includes solar panels that generate enough power to offset electricity and contribute back to the grid, along with three on-demand water heaters. Average total utilities (electricity, gas, and water) are just $112/month. A reinforced storage room with concrete walls, ceiling, and floor adds exceptional utility and security. Zoned for up to 4 horses and including 1 acre-foot of water rights, this property is ideal for those seeking space, self-sufficiency, and room to create. Enjoy mountain living with temperatures typically 10-15 degrees cooler than St. George, while still being within easy reach of both St. George and Cedar City. A rare opportunity to own a truly unique Southern Utah escape.
Property Type
Residential
Property Style
Single Family Residence
Architectural Style
Rambler/Ranch
Stories
1
Subdivision
KOLOB RANCH ESTATES
County
Washington
Zoning
Single-Family
Construction
Stucco,Metal Siding
Lot Size
5 sq ft
Above Grade Area
3,725 sq ft
Condition
Blt./Standing
MLS #
2155476
Property Type
Residential
Property Style
Single Family Residence
Architectural Style
Rambler/Ranch
Stories
1
Subdivision
KOLOB RANCH ESTATES
County
Washington
Zoning
Single-Family
Construction
Stucco,Metal Siding
Lot Size
5 sq ft
Above Grade Area
3,725 sq ft
Condition
Blt./Standing
MLS #
2155476
List Price
$1,190,000
Annual Taxes
$3,335
Home Warranty
No
List Price
$1,190,000
Annual Taxes
$3,335
Home Warranty
No
Heating
Gas: Central,Active Solar
Cooling
Central Air
Roof
Metal
Flooring
Concrete
Basement
Slab
Materials
Stucco,Metal Siding
Patio & Porch
Patio: Open
Water Source
Culinary,Rights: Owned
Sewer
Sewer: Connected
View
Mountain(s),Valley
Heating
Gas: Central,Active Solar
Cooling
Central Air
Roof
Metal
Flooring
Concrete
Basement
Slab
Materials
Stucco,Metal Siding
Patio & Porch
Patio: Open
Water Source
Culinary,Rights: Owned
Sewer
Sewer: Connected
View
Mountain(s),Valley
Garage Spaces
3
Covered Spaces
3
Total Parking
3
Garage Spaces
3
Covered Spaces
3
Total Parking
3
Classification
Standard
Deal Score
25/100
vs Market Median
12% above
Area Growth (YoY)
2.1%
Deal Score Breakdown
25/100
2.1% year-over-year ZHVI growth in this area
Priced 12% above the per-subtype city median
LT net cashflow -$3,691/mo (-47.4% return on ownership cost) · STR net cashflow -$4,817/mo (-61.8% return). Uses the better of LT or STR against total monthly ownership cost (P&I, tax, insurance, HOA, maintenance).
No price reduction from original list
Not enough comparable listings
Ensemble scoring: the best single signal sets the floor, secondary qualifying signals (≥60) each add 5 points up to +20. A home that strongly wins on one dimension is already a great deal — it doesn't need to tick every box.
Monthly Rent
$4,663/mo
Range: $3,387 – $5,938
Net Monthly Cash Flow
−$3,691 /mo (−$44,298/yr)
Monthly rental income
Monthly ownership cost
Coverage
60%
Net /mo
−$3,691
DSCR
0.69
Est. Annual Revenue
$51,037/yr
$274/night · 72% occupancy · $96/bedroom · $0.16/sqft
Net Monthly Cash Flow
−$4,817 /mo (−$57,809/yr)
Monthly STR income
Monthly ownership cost
Coverage
55%
Net /mo
−$4,817
DSCR
0.50
Best Download
1 Gbps
Best Upload
1 Gbps
Fiber Available
Yes
Providers
8
Available Providers
$3,335
Select agents you’d like to hear from. They’ll be notified of your interest — your contact details stay private until you choose to respond.

Devin Tanner - Utah Realtor
Your inquiry goes to the listing agent.
Fast Response
Typically within 2 hours during business hours
Built with AI to help you find your perfect home
Powered by AI • Secured by Supabase • Trusted by Agents