1140 HOYTSVILLE, Coalville, UT 84017
3BD/—BA Residential in Coalville, UT 84017. 1,678 sqft. Built 1898. Listed at $799,000. MLS #2165551.
3BD/—BA Residential in Coalville, UT 84017. 1,678 sqft. Built 1898. Listed at $799,000. MLS #2165551.
Versatile Country Property with Equestrian Space, Guest Cottage, Greenhouse & Established Income Opportunities in Coalville Discover a unique country property that offers the rare combination of peaceful country living and built-in income potential. The property has previously operated a successful upstairs Airbnb rental as well as an established horse motel business, creating multiple revenue streams while still offering plenty of flexibility for personal use. Inside the main home, you'll find a thoughtfully updated kitchen featuring sleek quartz countertops, premium appliances, and updated flooring that brings both style and functionality to the heart of the home. Two secluded outdoor decks extend the living space, providing the perfect setting to unwind, entertain, or simply take in the surrounding scenery. Equestrian enthusiasts will appreciate the pasture and tack shed, ready to accommodate your animals or support continued business use. A separate detached cottage adds even more versatility and can easily function as a guest retreat, private office, creative studio, or additional living space. The detached garage offers convenient covered parking along with extra storage space, while the greenhouse allows for year-round gardening. Situated on a beautiful 1-acre lot just off S. Hoytsville Road, this property offers privacy, open space, and picturesque mountain views of Lewis Peak, while remaining close to everyday conveniences. Enjoy quick access to world-class recreation and nearby amenities with Park City just 18 minutes away, Salt Lake City and the international airport approximately 46 minutes away, and the shops, dining, and charm of historic Coalville only 6 minutes from your doorstep. Whether you're looking for a private escape, an equestrian property, or an investment opportunity with proven income streams, this one-of-a-kind Coalville property delivers a rare opportunity to enjoy it all. Square footage figures are provided as a courtesy estimate only and were obtained from county records. Buyer is advised to obtain an independent measurement.
Property Type
Residential
Property Style
Single Family Residence
Architectural Style
Bungalow/Cottage
Stories
2
Subdivision
NORTH SUMMIT
County
Summit
Zoning
Short Term Rental Allowed
Construction
Other
Lot Size
1.08 sq ft
Above Grade Area
1,678 sq ft
Condition
Blt./Standing
MLS #
2165551
Property Type
Residential
Property Style
Single Family Residence
Architectural Style
Bungalow/Cottage
Stories
2
Subdivision
NORTH SUMMIT
County
Summit
Zoning
Short Term Rental Allowed
Construction
Other
Lot Size
1.08 sq ft
Above Grade Area
1,678 sq ft
Condition
Blt./Standing
MLS #
2165551
List Price
$799,000
Annual Taxes
$2,422
Home Warranty
No
List Price
$799,000
Annual Taxes
$2,422
Home Warranty
No
Heating
Heat Pump
Cooling
Central Air
Roof
Asphalt
Flooring
Vinyl
Basement
None
Materials
Other
Appliances
Gas Grill/BBQ
Patio & Porch
Covered,Porch: Open
Water Source
Irrigation
Sewer
Septic Tank
View
Mountain(s)
Heating
Heat Pump
Cooling
Central Air
Roof
Asphalt
Flooring
Vinyl
Basement
None
Materials
Other
Appliances
Gas Grill/BBQ
Patio & Porch
Covered,Porch: Open
Water Source
Irrigation
Sewer
Septic Tank
View
Mountain(s)
Garage Spaces
1
Covered Spaces
1
Total Parking
5
Garage Spaces
1
Covered Spaces
1
Total Parking
5
Classification
Standard
Deal Score
45/100
vs Market Median
1% above
Area Growth (YoY)
3.3%
Deal Score Breakdown
45/100
3.3% year-over-year ZHVI growth in this area
Priced 1% above the per-subtype city median
LT net cashflow -$2,474/mo (-46.9% return on ownership cost) · STR net cashflow -$4,290/mo (-81.3% return). Uses the better of LT or STR against total monthly ownership cost (P&I, tax, insurance, HOA, maintenance).
No price reduction from original list
Not enough comparable listings
Ensemble scoring: the best single signal sets the floor, secondary qualifying signals (≥60) each add 5 points up to +20. A home that strongly wins on one dimension is already a great deal — it doesn't need to tick every box.
Why this classification
Monthly Rent
$3,187/mo
Range: $1,724 – $4,649
Net Monthly Cash Flow
−$2,473 /mo (−$29,676/yr)
Monthly rental income
Monthly ownership cost
Coverage
60%
Net /mo
−$2,474
DSCR
0.70
Est. Annual Revenue
$16,943/yr
$180/night · 44% occupancy · $128/bedroom · $0.17/sqft
Net Monthly Cash Flow
−$4,290 /mo (−$51,481/yr)
Monthly STR income
Monthly ownership cost
Coverage
27%
Net /mo
−$4,290
DSCR
0.25
School District
North Summit
$547,000
+46% vs median
120 days
40
$300,000 – $4,475,000
$2,422
Select agents you’d like to hear from. They’ll be notified of your interest — your contact details stay private until you choose to respond.

Salt Lake City Real Estate Broker Focused on Pricing, Positioning, and Results

Daryn Edmunds - High Road Properties
Your inquiry goes to the listing agent.
Fast Response
Typically within 2 hours during business hours
Built with AI to help you find your perfect home
Powered by AI • Secured by Supabase • Trusted by Agents