Homes for Sale in Fillmore Utah: Market Update May 2026 | Propaired

Fillmore Utah Real Estate Market Update: May 2026 - A First-Time Buyer's Guide

Looking for homes for sale in Fillmore Utah? You've picked an interesting time to explore our charming rural community! As someone who's called Fillmore home for years and watched countless neighbors find their perfect property, I'm excited to share what's happening in our local market right now. With 24 active listings and a median price of $380K, there's never been a better selection for first-time buyers ready to embrace the outdoor lifestyle that makes Fillmore special. Let's dive into what the numbers tell us about buying a home in our corner of Millard County.

Current Market Snapshot: What First-Time Buyers Need to Know

The Fillmore real estate market 2026 presents a unique opportunity for first-time buyers. With 24 homes currently available and 13.7 months of inventory, we're firmly in buyer's market territory – meaning you have time to be selective and negotiate.

Here's what stands out in our current market:

Price range: $270K to $1.2M (something for every budget!)
Median list price: $380K (perfectly positioned for first-time buyers)
Upper quartile: $426K
Luxury threshold: $512K+ (only 4 luxury listings currently)

What I love about these numbers is how they reflect Fillmore's accessibility. Unlike Utah's major metros where first-time buyers often feel priced out, our market offers genuine affordability with room to grow.

Why 13.7 Months of Inventory Matters

This high inventory level means sellers are motivated and buyers have leverage. You won't face the bidding wars common in Salt Lake City or Provo. Take your time, inspect thoroughly, and don't be afraid to negotiate on price or repairs.

Market Trends: What the Data Reveals About Fillmore's Direction

The recent market activity tells a fascinating story. Looking at our 6-month trend, we've seen some interesting patterns that smart buyers should understand.

Recent closed sales show significant variation:

November 2025: $354K median, 309 days on market
December 2025: $565K median, 78 days on market
January 2026: $329K median, 75 days on market
February 2026: $182K median, 44 days on market
March 2026: $340K median, just 6 days on market!

The year-over-year comparison reveals stability with opportunity:

Prices down slightly (-0.7%)
Days on market up (+38%)
Same number of closed sales

This data suggests a market that's finding its equilibrium after the post-pandemic volatility. For first-time buyers, this translates to more negotiating power and less pressure to make hasty decisions.

The March Surprise: What 6 Days on Market Tells Us

That March sale closing in just 6 days? It shows that well-priced, quality homes still move quickly in Fillmore. The key is realistic pricing and good condition – something to remember when you find 'the one.'

Lifestyle Properties: Fillmore's Unique Appeal for Outdoor Enthusiasts

What makes buying a home in Fillmore Utah special isn't just the affordability – it's the lifestyle. Our current listings showcase exactly why people fall in love with rural Utah living.

Top property features in our current market:

7 hunting/outdoor properties – Perfect for those who want easy access to Utah's incredible hunting and fishing
7 investor specials – Great opportunities for first-time buyers willing to put in some sweat equity
6 equestrian properties – Horse lovers, this is your moment!

Living here means you're minutes from the Fishlake National Forest, with world-class hunting, fishing, and hiking literally in your backyard. I've watched neighbors bag elk from properties that cost less than a downtown Salt Lake condo. That's the Fillmore advantage.

Investor Specials: Hidden Gems for Savvy First-Time Buyers

Those 7 investor specials aren't just for landlords. Many represent fantastic opportunities for first-time buyers who don't mind some DIY projects. With current mortgage rates at 6.37%, buying a fixer-upper can help you build equity while creating your dream home.

The Equestrian Advantage

Six equestrian properties in a market of 24 listings? That's 25% of our inventory! Whether you currently own horses or dream of that lifestyle, Fillmore offers acreage and horse facilities that would cost millions closer to urban areas.

Economic Context: Interest Rates and Market Timing

Let's talk about the elephant in the room: mortgage rates at 6.37%. Yes, they're higher than the pandemic lows, but here's the local perspective that matters for Fillmore buyers.

Current economic indicators:

30-year mortgage rates: 6.37%
Utah unemployment: 3.6% (healthy job market)
Real estate sentiment: 67.4 (cautiously optimistic)

While 6.37% might seem high compared to recent years, it's actually reasonable historically. More importantly, in Fillmore's market, the combination of motivated sellers and high inventory often means you can negotiate purchase prices that offset higher borrowing costs.

I've seen first-time buyers secure $15K-20K in seller concessions or price reductions – money that goes directly toward your down payment or closing costs. That's real savings that compound over time.

The First-Time Buyer Advantage in Today's Market

With 13.7 months of inventory, sellers know they need to be competitive. First-time buyer programs, combined with seller concessions, can make homeownership surprisingly affordable even at current rates.

Neighborhood Insights: Where to Focus Your Search

Having helped friends and neighbors navigate Fillmore's market for years, I've learned that location matters differently here than in urban areas. It's less about school districts and commute times, and more about lifestyle fit and long-term value.

Prime areas for first-time buyers:

Central Fillmore: Close to amenities, established neighborhoods, typically in the $300K-400K range. Perfect for buyers who want the convenience of walking to local businesses.

Rural outskirts: Where those hunting and equestrian properties shine. Slightly higher prices but massive value in terms of acreage and privacy.

Investor special zones: Often older homes with great bones, perfect for buyers with vision and some DIY skills.

The beauty of Fillmore is that even our "outskirts" are only minutes from town center. You're never truly isolated, but you can find the peace and space that drew many of us here in the first place.

Future Growth Considerations

While Fillmore maintains its rural character, smart buyers look for properties with development potential or proximity to planned infrastructure improvements. The key is balancing current affordability with long-term appreciation potential.

The Fillmore Utah housing market in May 2026 offers first-time buyers something increasingly rare: choice, affordability, and time to make smart decisions. With 24 active listings, a median price of $380K, and 13.7 months of inventory, you're shopping in a true buyer's market.

Whether you're drawn to our hunting properties, equestrian lifestyle, or simply want affordable homeownership in beautiful rural Utah, now is an excellent time to explore what Fillmore has to offer. The combination of motivated sellers, diverse inventory, and stable economic conditions creates opportunities that won't last forever.

Ready to start your home search? Visit Propaired's Fillmore listings to explore all 24 current properties, or connect with our local agents who understand this market inside and out. Your Fillmore adventure starts with the right information – and you've got it.

Market data and insights provided by Propaired Market Intelligence. For the most current listings and market updates, visit propaired.ai.

Listings in Fillmore